The Top Specialized High Schools In New York City – Save Our Schools March

Introduction

As a city renowned for its vibrant culture and ethnic diversity, New York is home to some of the top specialized public high schools in the nation. These schools offer academically gifted students access to a rigorous curriculum, stellar college preparation, and concentrations in fields like science, technology, humanities, civics, and the arts.

Admission into these prestigious schools is highly competitive. Students must pass the Specialized High School Admissions Test (SHSAT), a standardized exam that evaluates math and verbal skills. This singular focus on exam performance has led to intense debate around diversity and equitable access.

As New Yorkers march today to "save our schools" from proposed changes to the SHSAT system, it‘s important we have nuanced discussions around balancing merit-based admissions with policies that give talented youth from all backgrounds a shot at success.

As an Education Reform Expert who has analyzed admission policies and student outcomes at specialized schools across the country, I provide an in-depth look at the top SHSAT schools in NYC. These include Stuyvesant High School, Bronx High School of Science, Brooklyn Technical High School, Brooklyn Latin School, High School of American Studies at Lehman College, and Fiorello H. LaGuardia High School.

For each school, I assess the unique curriculum, culture, admissions process, and notable alumni, while examining the debate around access and diversity. The goal is to celebrate these institutions while also spurring thoughtful dialogue on potential improvements.

Stuyvesant High School

Overview: Established in 1904, Stuyvesant is the city‘s oldest specialized school. Located in Lower Manhattan, it is renowned for excellence in math, science, and technology. Its strong STEM curriculum allows students to earn up to 14 AP credits.

Unique Programs: Stuyvesant has an Engineering Institute providing research and design opportunities. The Computer Science Institute offers advanced courses and internships. Rotating schedules foster critical thinking across disciplines.

Academic Rigor and Support: Stuyvesant‘s 2,900 students attend 7:20am – 5:00pm. The curriculum emphasizes math, science, and problem-solving. Support includes peer tutoring, review sessions, and guidance counseling.

College Acceptance and Outcomes: Over 90% of students pursue STEM majors. The school reports a 99% college acceptance rate. Notable alumni include Nobel laureates, scientists, CEOs, and politicians.

Admissions and Access: Of 900 freshman seats, offers to Black and Latino students dropped from 13% in 2019 to only 10% in 2022, indicating a diversity crisis. Just 3% of offers went to Black students, who make up 24% of the city‘s enrollment.

Table 1. Stuyvesant Demographics and Admissions Offers, 2022

Ethnicity Offers Received NYC Public School Enrollment
Asian 74% 16%
White 13% 15%
Black 3% 24%
Latino 10% 41%

Sources: NYC Department of Education, Specialized High School Institute

The lack of diversity results from admissions depending solely on the SHSAT. Excellence and equity are not mutually exclusive. Policies like free prep programs and multiple admission measures could expand access while maintaining rigor.

Stuyvesant offers students a premier STEM education. To fulfill its mission, however, the school should better reflect NYC‘s diversity and nurture talent in underserved communities.

Bronx High School of Science

Overview: Founded in 1938, Bronx Science emphasizes STEM and humanities education. The school boasts an elite academic environment with 11 science labs and courses like organic chemistry, astrophysics, and AP Computer Science Principles.

Unique Programs: Bronx Science hosts a prestigious Intel Science competition and research teams tackling cutting-edge work in STEM fields. Students participate in math team, Model United Nations, speech/debate, and nationally recognized Junior Statesmen of America.

Academic Rigor and Support: The curriculum emphasizes college preparation through honors, Advanced Placement (AP), and electives. Support includes guidance counseling, tutoring, and prep for specialized exams.

College Acceptance and Outcomes: The school reports a college acceptance rate of over 95%. Notable alumni include 8 Nobel laureates, NASA scientists, academics, and a Supreme Court justice.

Admissions and Access: Of about 800 seats, only 10% of offers went to Black and Latino students combined in 2022, though they represent 65% of the city‘s enrollment. Offers to White students also decreased by half, while Asian students received 70% of seats.

Table 2. Bronx Science Demographics and Admissions Offers, 2022

Ethnicity Offers Received NYC Public School Enrollment
Asian 70% 16%
White 20% 15%
Black 4% 24%
Latino 6% 41%

Sources: NYC Department of Education, Specialized High School Institute

Like other specialized schools, these alarming disparities result from overreliance on a single exam. A holistic review could maintain selectivity while opening doors for low-income, gifted students of color. Bronx Science offers world-class STEM preparation, but must ensure talent is nurtured equitably.

Brooklyn Technical High School

Overview: Founded in 1922, Brooklyn Tech is the largest specialized high school, serving over 5,800 students. It focuses on college preparation and STEM education through engineering, biotech, physics, law, and computer science courses.

Unique Programs: Students gain hands-on experience through the school‘s engineering and computer science institutes. Fab Lab provides access to 3D printing and prototyping technology. Partnerships with tech firms and universities provide research opportunities.

Academic Rigor and Support: The comprehensive curriculum includes honors, 14 AP courses, and electives. Rotating schedules allow focus on fewer subjects. Support includes mentoring, tutoring, and guidance resources.

College Acceptance and Outcomes: Brooklyn Tech reports a college acceptance rate of over 95%. Notable alumni include CEOs of Pfizer, Arby‘s, and Citigroup, plus Nobel laureates, engineers, and scientists.

Admissions and Access: Of 1,800 seats, only 5% of offers went to Black students and 7% to Latinos in 2022. Black and Latino students make up 65% of the city‘s enrollment, indicating vast disparity.

Table 3. Brooklyn Technical High School Demographics and Admissions Offers, 2022

Ethnicity Offers Received NYC Public School Enrollment
Asian 69% 16%
White 19% 15%
Black 5% 24%
Latino 7% 41%

Sources: NYC Department of Education, Specialized High School Institute

Brooklyn Tech offers STEM opportunities on par with top private schools. However, relying solely on SHSAT scores excludes gifted low-income students. A holistic review could maintain standards while creating education equity.

Brooklyn Latin School

Overview: Founded in 2006, Brooklyn Latin focuses on humanities education, with intensive Latin and Greek language programs. The curriculum prioritizes rhetoric, philosophy, literature, history, and analytical writing.

Unique Programs: Students take four years of Latin and Greek. The school hosts a Junior Classical League for competitions and scholarships. Students participate in Model Congress and deliver TED Talks on issues like social justice.

Academic Rigor and Support: The curriculum emphasizes critical thinking, reasoned debate, and disciplined study. Students take rhetoric all four years, read foundational texts, and develop college-level writing skills. Support includes tutoring and guidance counseling.

College Acceptance and Outcomes: The school boasts a 99% graduation rate and 96% college acceptance rate. Notable alumni include Supreme Court Justices Sonia Sotomayor and Ruth Bader Ginsburg.

Admissions and Access: Of 150 spots, only 4% of offers went to Black students and 10% to Latinos in 2022. Offers to White students also dropped 50% between 2019 and 2022.

Table 4. Brooklyn Latin Demographics and Admissions Offers, 2022

Ethnicity Offers Received NYC Public School Enrollment
Asian 59% 16%
White 27% 15%
Black 4% 24%
Latino 10% 41%

Sources: NYC Department of Education, Specialized High School Institute

Brooklyn Latin provides humanities education on par with elite private schools. However, the lack of diversity underscores the need for admissions policies that identify well-rounded, gifted students through varied measures beyond just the SHSAT.

High School of American Studies at Lehman College

Overview: Founded in 2002, HSAS combines competitive liberal arts education with a focus on American history and civics. It is located on the Lehman College campus.

Unique Programs: Coursework includes Constitutional Law, Civil Rights, International Relations, and issues in American society. Students participate in Model UN, debate team, and government and policy internships.

Academic Rigor and Support: The curriculum emphasizes analytical writing, research, and reasoned debate around contemporary issues. Support includes writing workshops, faculty mentorships, guidance counselors, and peer tutoring.

College Acceptance and Outcomes: The school is ranked among the top high schools nationally, with a 100% graduation rate. Notable alumni include Dr. Anthony Fauci and Supreme Court Justice Sonia Sotomayor.

Admissions and Access: Of 108 seats, only 8% of offers went to Black and 13% to Latino students in 2022. However, HSAS is expanding its Discovery program from 20 to 68 seats to support high-potential students from disadvantaged backgrounds.

Table 5. HSAS Demographics and Admissions Offers, 2022

Ethnicity Offers Received NYC Public School Enrollment
Asian 46% 16%
White 33% 15%
Black 6% 24%
Latino 13% 41%

Sources: NYC Department of Education, Specialized High School Institute

While HSAS offers exceptional civic education, it must continue improving diversity. The expansion of its Discovery program shows promising steps in opening doors for low-income youth. More policies like this could strengthen its merit-based offerings.

Fiorello H. LaGuardia High School

Overview: LaGuardia, also called the "Fame School," opened in 1936 and focuses on performing arts alongside rigorous academics. Students pursue concentrations in dance, drama, fine arts, vocal or instrumental music.

Unique Programs: Students take academic courses while specializing in their artistic field. They put on over 30 theater productions, 50 concerts, and 4 dance concerts per year. The school partners with Lincoln Center, Carnegie Hall, and others.

Academic Rigor and Support: Students take advanced courses in English, history, math, science, and foreign languages. Arts electives allow focus on technique. Support includes tutoring, mentoring, and college counseling.

Admissions and Access: Students must demonstrate artistic talent through auditions and review of middle school records. While subjective, this process considers applicants holistically beyond just an exam. The population is more diverse than other specialized schools.

College Acceptance and Outcomes: Over 98% of students pursue college, with top acceptances to Juilliard, NYU, and top art schools. Notable alumni include Jennifer Aniston, Nicki Minaj, Sarah Michelle Gellar, and Al Pacino.

LaGuardia provides world-class arts education that nurtures NYC‘s creativity and culture. Its holistic admission process results in a more diverse, representative student body of talented youth. This model demonstrates how schools can broaden access beyond academics-only testing while upholding artistic rigor.

Conclusion: Celebrating Excellence and Expanding Access

New York City‘s specialized high schools offer unmatched math, science, humanities, civics, and arts education that cultivate future leaders and innovators. However, current admissions relying solely on SHSAT scores fail to identify talented, motivated students from disadvantaged backgrounds.

As New Yorkers march to "save our schools" from proposals like eliminating the SHSAT, we must seek balanced solutions. Policies like making free, quality test prep widely available and incorporating factors like grades, essays, and interviews into the process could maintain rigor while creating equity of access.

Through nuanced debate and a shared vision of excellence, New York‘s specialized high schools can continue nurturing diverse talent. Our future scientists, humanists, artists, and leaders demonstrate that expanding access uplifts us all. Together, we can ensure America‘s best public education is open to students of all backgrounds.

Similar Posts