Is Project CARS 2 or Project CARS 3 Better?
Without question, Project CARS 2 is the superior game for those looking for an authentic, rewarding sim racing experience. Having spent over 200 hours across both titles, I can confidently say PCARS 2 delivers where it matters – precision handling, competitive multiplayer, and long-term replay value. Read on for an in-depth look at the key differences.
Visuals and Immersion
While neither game would be considered cutting-edge by 2023‘s graphical standards, Project CARS 2 better instills the sensation of sitting in a real race car. The visibility from cockpit view feels more true-to-life, with carefully modeled interiors and working gauges for over 180 vehicles. Crisp 4K resolution showcases details from worn tire treads to specular lighting on bodywork. Plus, the original track scans capture ultra-precise topography data for laser-accurate reproductions of iconic circuits like Spa-Francorchamps and the Nordschleife.
Project CARS 3 adopted a cleaner, more saturated visual style that lacks some realism. Car models appear less detailed inside and out. The HDR implementation also seems less impactful compared to PCARS 2‘s impressive dynamic range. All told, PCARS 2‘s graphics better complement its hardcore simulation aspirations.
Winner: Project CARS 2
Physics and Handling
The in-house MADNESS engine powering Project CARS 2 was engineered specifically for competitive racing physics. Independent suspension, weight transfer, intricate tire dynamics, and advanced aerodynamics come together to achieve an unparalleled sense of connection with over 100 vehicle classes ranging from karts to Le Mans prototypes. Subtle details like "stick slip" traction effects add further realism that translates palpably through force feedback wheels.
By contrast, Project CARS 3 simplified physics significantly. Buggies handle more like drift cars, open wheel formulas lack authentic grip limits, and weight transfer feels far more scripted. This may appeal to casual players, but offers little incentive for aspiring aliens hunting for tenth-of-a-second gains. Overall, Project CARS 2 better rewards driving skill through its supremely intuitive yet demanding handling.
Winner: Project CARS 2
Career and Progression
Project CARS 2 features one of the most flexible career modes found in simulation racing. Players start out in karts or entry-level vehicles, earning seats in faster cars through strong performances in various series. Custom championship creator and test drive features allow dialing in car setups or hosting endurance events.
Project CARS 3 overhauled progression into a more structured system with predefined event tiers. Some appreciated the increased direction, but ultimately there is less freedom to plot your own path up the motorsports ladder compared to PCARS 2. Upgrades also focus on visual customization over performance tuning.
Winner: Project CARS 2
Career Progression Comparison
| Feature | Project CARS 2 | Project CARS 3 |
|---|---|---|
| Open Championships | Yes | No |
| Custom Multi-Class Races | Yes | No |
| In-Depth Setups | Yes | Reduced |
| Performance Upgrades | Yes | Mostly Visual |
| Free Test Drives | Yes | Restricted |
Multiplayer and Esports
Project CARS 2 sets the gold standard for competitive online racing and leagues. The ranking system ensures close, clean matches against similarly-skilled drivers. Scheduled events, time trials, and racing clubs provide avenues for aspiring esports pros. Even after several years, the online community remains highly active with packed grids commonplace.
Project CARS 3 generally failed to achieve the same multiplayer traction. Ranked racing was oddly excluded at launch, eroding the potential for an esports scene. While updates later added ranking, small participant numbers and questionable collision penalties continue hampering online competition to this day. There is simply no contest here.
Winner: Project CARS 2
Post-Launch Support
Slightly Mad Studios has demonstrated admirable long-term dedication to the Project CARS franchise, releasing a steady stream of updates, paid DLC, and discounted bundles to provide excellent value for players. Project CARS 2 receives regular bug fixes even 6 years post-launch, not to mention official mod support adding extras like new tracks.
As a newer title, Project CARS 3 had an opportunity to replicate this success. However, patches and optimizations rapidly declined after lackluster reception. Much-requested features like VR support remain absent while certain annoying glitches persist unresolved. Disappointingly, meaningful updates appear halted, diminishing hopes for a comeback.
Winner: Project CARS 2
Verdict
While the direction of Project CARS 3 offered more accessibility, the end result failed to do either arcade or simulation fans many favors. Conversely, Project CARS 2 remains unmatched for delivering supremely polished, hardcore racing worth mastering year after year. For any motorsports gaming fan deciding where to spend their money, Project CARS 2 is clearly the superior choice.
