M4A1 vs SCAR: In-Depth Modern Warfare Weapon Comparison

As a hardcore Call of Duty player and content creator, I get asked constantly about what the current best rifle is–the reliable M4A1 or heavy-hitting SCAR. After extensive in-game testing and crunching the stats, I believe the M4A1 is the strongest overall but the SCAR outclasses it at longer ranges. Keep reading for a full breakdown on every key performance metric before you choose your new favorite assault rifle!

Overview

As you can see from base stats, these two fall into familiar archetypes: the M4A1 brings versatility and ease-of-use while the SCAR offers raw stopping power from afar. Keep reading for an in-depth analysis on how these weapons compare across critical performance criteria.

Speed

Let‘s start with handling and mobility since reaction time is everything in Call of Duty.

With superior sprint out and Aim Down Sights (ADS) times, the M4A1 builds its case as the rushing rifle of choice. The small but noticeable differences here give M4A1 users an edge getting shots off first in close quarters.

Firepower Up Close

Most firefights occur under 100 feet so damage potential within this range is make-or-break.

Within extreme close quarters, the damage profile is nearly identical and the M4A1‘s raw fire rate gives it a slightly faster theoretical time-to-kill against a full plated opponent.

Mid-Range Duels

Stretching out gunfights is where the long-barreled SCAR starts to flex its muscles.

With a 5-shot kill out to 38 meters, the SCAR catches up significantly with its heavier caliber at range. The playing field looks dead even until you factor for accuracy.

Recoil Control

Staying on target is crucial past 50 feet as assault rifles start climbing. Here‘s how the M4A1 and SCAR compare when fully kitted for recoil stabilization:

While the SCAR can be tamed, mathematically the M4A1 will bounce less making follow up shots easier. The visual pattern also favors the M4A1 staying truer upwards instead of shifting horizontally off target.

Damage Range

Extending damage dropoff is where the SCAR‘s heavier rounds make a difference.

With the right attachments, the SCAR dominates longest distance engagements by keeping its 5-shot kill potential past 50 meters.

Fire Rate Cap

For trigger fingers, the SCAR‘s semi-auto efficiency can‘t quite match the blistering fully-automatic M4A1.

So while the SCAR is a powerhouse, the M4A1‘s unmatched fire rate gives it another close-medium range advantage.

Best Loadouts

Both rifles can be tuned through Gunsmith to specialized roles. Here are my favorite M4A1 and SCAR builds right now for range and aggressiveness:

Long Range M4A1

Attachments:

• Monolithic Suppressor
• Corvus Barrel
• Commando Foregrip
• 60 Round Mags
• VLK Optic

This loadout minimizes vertical climb while maximizing damage range for mid-long poke battles.

CQC BEAST SCAR

Attachments:

• FORGE TAC CQC Pro Barrel
• 5mW Laser
• Stippled Grip Tape
• 30 Round Mags
• No Stock

Built for hipfire speed, this setup allows the SCAR to dominate close quarters if you can handle the recoil.

In Summary

After scrutinizing every stat and build option, I believe the M4A1 by a hair thanks to its versatility and ease of control. The SCAR is an absolute freight train past 50 feet but gets outmaneuvered up close. Let me know which rifle you prefer in the comments and I‘ll see you next time!